What is a shortlist?

A shortlist is a targeted selection of providers or solutions that have been filtered out of a more comprehensive longlist. It serves as the basis for a detailed evaluation of the best options. Companies use the shortlist to prepare a final decision and focus on the best-performing solutions.

Role of the shortlist in IT and ERP projects

In the B2B environment, creating a shortlist is an essential step in the selection of ERP systemssoftware solutions or IT service providers. While the longlist serves to gain a broad overview of the market, only the most promising candidates are considered in the shortlist.

The shortlist enables companies to focus on solutions that have a high level of compliance with the defined requirements. Not only functional aspects are considered, but also factors such as economic viability, implementation costs and long-term strategic benefits.

Advantages of a shortlist

  • Better decision-making: Detailed evaluation minimizes the risk of wrong decisions.
  • Increased efficiency: Concentrating on a small number of highly relevant providers speeds up the evaluation process.
  • Detailed examination: Companies can carry out in-depth analyses, tests and reference discussions.
  • Improved negotiating position: A reduced list of suppliers facilitates targeted contract negotiations.

Steps for creating a shortlist for ERP systems

  1. Detailed analysis of the longlist candidates: The providers are shortlisted on the basis of a precise evaluation.
  2. In-depth discussions with providers: Initial discussions, product demos and evaluation workshops provide information on practical suitability.
  3. Consideration of the cost structure: In addition to acquisition costs, implementation, maintenance and support costs are also evaluated.
  4. Obtain experiences from other companies: Customer references and independent reviews play an important role.
  5. Finalization of the shortlist: The most suitable providers are included in the final selection before a final decision is made.

Template for an ERP shortlist

ERP shortlist blank template

CriterionDescriptionRating (1-5)
Company dataProvider name, website, contact person
Industry focusIs the ERP system optimized for your industry?
Range of functionsDoes the system meet your core requirements?
ScalabilityCan the software grow with your company?
Integration capabilityCompatibility with existing systems?
User friendlinessIs the system intuitive to use?
Cost structureAcquisition costs, license model, running costs
Support & MaintenanceAvailability of support and services
References & ReviewsExperiences of other companies
Legal & safety aspectsGDPR compliance, security standards

Conclusion

The shortlist is an indispensable tool for informed decision-making in IT and ERP projects. It enables companies to use a structured approach to filter out the best providers and focus on the most relevant solutions.

A systematic approach to creating the shortlist ensures a transparent basis for decision-making and reduces potential risks. Companies benefit from better comparison options, more efficient selection processes and greater certainty in the final decision. This targeted approach ensures that the implemented solution fits in perfectly with the corporate strategy and offers added value in the long term.

Whitepaper ERP vendor selection: Get the most out of your ERP workshops

Free Whitepaper

There are countless ERP providers. Read on to find out what you need to look out for when making your choice.
Request now for free

FAQ about Shortlist

What is a shortlist?

A shortlist is a reduced selection of providers or solutions that is drawn up after an initial, more comprehensive pre-selection (longlist) and contains only those candidates that meet all of a company’s key requirements.

Why is a shortlist created?

The shortlist serves to focus the selection process and conserve resources by shortlisting only the best-qualified providers – so the decision can be prepared in a more efficient and targeted manner.

How does the transition from the longlist to the shortlist typically work?

First, a broad market overview is compiled in the form of a longlist , then providers are sorted out on the basis of defined evaluation criteria, resulting in a smaller, practical shortlist that usually contains two to four candidates.

What criteria are relevant when creating a shortlist?

Criteria such as functional scope, integration capability, cost structure, scalability, industry focus, support services and references play a role in the selection process for the shortlist.

How does the shortlist relate to an ERP project?

As part of an ERP project, a shortlist is used to shortlist only those ERP providers whose systems best map the specific company processes and offer the best framework conditions – thus optimizing the decision-making process in a targeted manner for implementation.

What are the advantages of a clearly formulated shortlist for companies?

A clearly formulated shortlist provides a structured basis for decision-making, reduces the time and costs involved in the selection process, makes it easier to compare providers and increases the likelihood that the selected solution will be a long-term fit for the company.